A Dog's Purpose...

Posted by: MaxaLisa

A Dog's Purpose... - 01/19/17 12:23 PM

I guess it's a movie coming out - some controversy about how some of the animals were treated. A clip of the movie is in the second link frown

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/leak...81a304?37toi529

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/leak...81a304?37toi529
Posted by: Mary Jane

Re: A Dog's Purpose... - 01/19/17 01:11 PM

WARNING!!!!

The second link has a video of a very scared GSD (although the breed doesn't matter I guess) desperately trying to avoid being pushed into some kind of turbulent water. It's AWFUL!

so much for the film frown........
Posted by: middleofnowhere

Re: A Dog's Purpose... - 01/19/17 02:43 PM

From what I saw, I didn't think it was so bad. I think we all know that some dogs can really resist water when you want them to get in it. With dogs and horses, they often resist pressure rather than yeilding to it.

On the other hand, show biz has a history of less than fine treatment of animals. Take a look into how they made those scenes with horses in older movies. Who knows what they did with cattle (but we don't care about cattle because after all we use pretty brutal slaughter techniques and eat them). So basically, the use of the GSD shown seems pretty mild to me.
Posted by: lhczth

Re: A Dog's Purpose... - 01/19/17 04:08 PM

The one video is so heavily edited, there is no way to know what actually happened. AND, why, when this video was filmed in 2015, did the AR slanting group wait to post the video until now? Think, don't just react because that is what they want.
Posted by: SeanRescueMom

Re: A Dog's Purpose... - 01/19/17 06:10 PM

Originally Posted By: Mary Jane
The second link has a video of a very scared GSD (although the breed doesn't matter I guess) desperately trying to avoid being pushed into some kind of turbulent water. It's AWFUL!


I had to turn away, it was painful to watch! shocked
Posted by: MaxaLisa

Re: A Dog's Purpose... - 01/20/17 01:59 AM

It was difficult to watch frown
Posted by: BasiaBear

Re: A Dog's Purpose... - 01/20/17 05:18 PM

Although I think there are better methods of getting that scene done (training technique or even just a more confident and driven dog) I really don't think it was that bad. Dogs act like huge babies and are overly dramatic about the smallest things sometimes; nail trimming and bath time come to mind for Basia. I still make her do it.
Posted by: Braverhund

Re: A Dog's Purpose... - 01/20/17 09:55 PM

Honestly, the GSD breed has such a HUGE range of temperaments and drives, they could have gotten a ridiculously over-zealous dog like my Grimm to do the scene (He delights in terribly wild, nutty, risky situations).

I've had a gentle, soft-natured, sensitive GSD in the past. I can't even view the clip, the stills are more than I want to see. This is wrong and not necessary.

It would have taken very little time to find a too-bold, zany, fearless GSD for this brief scene.
Posted by: middleofnowhere

Re: A Dog's Purpose... - 01/21/17 12:16 PM

Further info on the not always reliable internet claims that the dog had no problem with water and working in those conditions until then. From my experience, I can buy that. It's a bit like in a trial "My dog's never done that before!" which I am sure every judge hears at least once a trial.
Posted by: Kayos

Re: A Dog's Purpose... - 01/24/17 08:06 AM

This has been all over Facebook. Yes the dog was stressed, yes, they stopped shooting and moved the dog back to the other side of the pool where he had been happily rehearsing the scene.The video going around was heavily edited and made to look much worse than it was. Sensationalism by none other than TADA!!!!!! PETA.
Posted by: SeanRescueMom

Re: A Dog's Purpose... - 01/25/17 10:08 AM

Originally Posted By: Kayos
The video going around was heavily edited and made to look much worse than it was. Sensationalism by none other than TADA!!!!!! PETA.


I heard on the Today Show this morning that the tape was made 15 mos. ago and, as you said, heavily edited. The movie will be in theaters this Friday, Jan. 27. I wonder what the turnout will be!
Posted by: middleofnowhere

Re: A Dog's Purpose... - 01/25/17 02:27 PM

I'm planning on seeing it when it comes to town.
Posted by: Islandgsds

Re: A Dog's Purpose... - 01/25/17 03:41 PM

Originally Posted By: Kayos
This has been all over Facebook. Yes the dog was stressed, yes, they stopped shooting and moved the dog back to the other side of the pool where he had been happily rehearsing the scene.The video going around was heavily edited and made to look much worse than it was. Sensationalism by none other than TADA!!!!!! PETA.


'nough said. eyeroll

I'd go see it.
Posted by: SeanRescueMom

Re: A Dog's Purpose... - 01/31/17 08:20 PM

Originally Posted By: middleofnowhere
I'm planning on seeing it when it comes to town.


DH and I saw the movie today. I teared up within the first 10 minutes, I'm so sentimental when it comes to animals especially dogs. Was it the best movie I ever saw? No. Was it predictable? Yes. But I'm still glad I saw it and fortunately it had a happy ending. smile
Posted by: middleofnowhere

Re: A Dog's Purpose... - 02/01/17 05:35 PM

Thanks for the review. It hasn't come to town yet here.
Posted by: Kayos

Re: A Dog's Purpose... - 02/08/17 08:10 AM

And recent findings say the entire video that was released was fabricated. Yes they did stress the dog and realized they stressed him too much and stopped shooting.
Posted by: PaddyD

Re: A Dog's Purpose... - 02/09/17 09:02 AM

I read the book. Kind of sappy.
But, hey, I read the whole book.
blush